The Iron Fist of Sensitivity
By BOB WARD
Editor of the Texas Journal
As the law increasingly leans toward making hurt feelings
actionable in court, or even the basis for criminal prosecution,
it is useful to look at a development in South Africa and
consider whether it is a sign of things to come here in the land
of the used to be free.
The Conservative News Service reports that South Africa has
enacted the Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair
Discrimination Act. It is considered a key piece of legislation
and all other laws will be amended, if necessary, to conform to
it.
The new law bans discrimination on the basis of "race, gender,
sex, pregnancy, marital status, ethnic or social origin, color,
sexual orientation, age, disability, religion, conscience,
belief, culture, language and birth."
It forbids not only discriminatory action but speech intended
to be hurtful, incite harm or promote hatred. For example, a
Christian preacher who says salvation is gained only through
Jesus Christ a basic tenet of many Christian sects could be
prosecuted because those who believe otherwise may be offended.
This recalls the time Gov. George W. Bush expressed such a belief
and critics called it offensive to Jews.
Alleged violators of the new law have to prove their innocence
in "equality courts." where they will. ties. They may be joined
by other lawmakers, gun dealers and private individuals who
realize the cities' lawsuits are really an attempt to impose
restrictions that would not survive constitutional challenge if
offered as legislation.
A spokesman for the African Christian Democratic Party , which
opposed by law, said including sexual orientation means clerics
who refuse to marry a same-sex couple or refuse to recognize such
a marriage could be prosecuted. Also, teaching that the Bible
condemns sodomy or calling on sinners to repent may be illegal.
Christian broadcasters, the spokesman said, are being monitor-ed
and could lose their license unless they adjust their message.
The reference to pregnancy could put in legal jeopardy anyone
who takes a public pro-life position. One critic of the law said
his organization, African Christian Action, took part in a
demonstration outside Parliament in which pro-lifers mourned the
100,000 babies killed since abortion was made legal in 1997. A
similar demonstration today, he said, could be illegal
discrimination against women who want to have abortions.
The new law was supported by the South African Council of
Churches which said it was "in keeping with the tenets of the
Christian faith."
Anyone who thinks similar measures will never happen here is
not paying attention. "Hate crime" laws punish people for what
they believe and feel. Persons have been fined and forced to
undergo psychological treatment for "insensitive" remarks.
Moral and religious objections to homosexuality are regularly
denounced sometimes officially as bigotry.
Many U.S. judges and lawmakers are too eager to violate
fundamental rights and due process to protect the tender feelings
of certain citizens. The example of South Africa should be a
warning to us. So-called sensitivty can be just another pretext
to grab power.